From what I understand of legal and judicial precedent, the Federal government is not supposed to interfere with a woman’s right to choose when, how and under what circumstances to have or not have a child. This includes the right to a safe and legal abortion as under the conditions of the Roe v. Wade United States Supreme Court decision of 1973.
Late last Saturday night, this right began unraveling in the House of Representatives. When the vote was over, the House had passed a comprehensive health care reform bill that essentially eliminates a woman’s right to choose abortion. The Stupak-Pitts amendment, which was included in the House bill, makes it illegal for any provider in the proposed health care exchange, the marketplace created for individuals and businesses, or in any public option, to provide abortion coverage.
Women would instead be able to purchase an abortion rider, additional coverage for abortion services. Anti-choice groups would have us believe that this is a reasonable compromise, but who would choose to pay extra for a service that they don’t ever expect to use? Women cannot anticipate unintended or untenable pregnancies. Furthermore, in the five states that have abortion rider requirements already, there is no evidence that such riders have ever been made available. Losing the right to purchase abortion coverage with their own funds puts women at risk. Low and middle income women who will need subsidies to purchase insurance, those who are in the greatest need of comprehensive and high quality health care, are left without options. The lives of women and their families literally hang in the balance.
The decision to have or not have an abortion should remain between a woman and her doctor; this amendment threatens to revoke the right to that decision and violates the very spirit of health care reform. Health care reform isn’t about promoting one ideology over another, it’s about the legal and moral rights of people to receive the comprehensive health care that they need and deserve – and not to be denied coverage of services that are currently covered by most insurance companies.
It’s extremely difficult for me to be happy about reform that doesn’t provide access to comprehensive reproductive health care for millions of women – so I’m not going to be. A health system that doesnt give us access to care we need is inherently unjust and unacceptable. So I’m going to believe that it will not be codified. I’m going to put my faith in the Unitarian Universalists and other champions of reproductive justice out there, and I’m going to believe in the power of advocacy.
But I need your help. I can’t do it without you. Please contact your Senators and the White House with a clear message telling them to enact health care reform that does not eliminate services that women already receive, including comprehensive reproductive care, including abortion.
Please, Take Action Now
One of the things that I find most upsetting is that they are leaving out a legal procedure. No other legal procedures are singled out.
My husband works for a Catholic healthcare system. This is their home page: http://www.ssfhs.org
The employee portal has a photo of a baby that says Healthcare respects ALL life.
I want to tell them that healtcare also respects women's rights and the law.